DS Cross Series – Tim Sullivan
Having enjoyed book 4 in the series, I went back to read the previous three: The Dentist, The Cyclist and The Patient. Then I went forward and read The Monk, The Teacher and The Bookseller. Each title refers to a murder victim who DS Cross will seek to understand to find their murderer. The plots are engaging and filled with compelling characters. Really solid reads, but not quite Wallander levels of brilliance, sorry I know that’s a high bar.
The Broken Afternoon – Simon Mason
My daughter picked this up over the Christmas holidays but didn’t manage to finish it before her return to university. Curious, I gave it a go. It’s a solid crime fiction detective mystery. The main characters are the un-related Ray Wilkins, a smooth well-educated detective; and Ryan Wilkins, a rough and rowdy youngster recently dismissed from the Police. Interesting characters and plot but not quite enough to make me want to reach for other books in the series. The main detectives just aren’t that likeable, which feels like a flaw when you’re creating a book series that hangs on them. I also found the descriptions of Oxford bordering on obsessive.
Clear – Carys Davies
The hyperbolic praise of this book, which naturally is plastered over the cover, probably didn’t help with my expectation management. There’s a lot going for it: An intriguing setting in 1840s Scotland as landlords clear their tenants in favour of cattle; beautifully described scenery and weather; and the outlines of interesting characters. But sadly, this short novel doesn’t deliver. The vaguely described denouement just doesn’t make sense. Some reviewers commented that the ending “hadn’t been earned” – maybe that, or it just did not feel in line with any of the characters as described. Disappointing I’m afraid. I know I find writing endings incredibly hard, so I do sympathise.
